It’s time to take another deep, dark look into one of the critters who infest The Nest with a healthy dose of fuckeduppedness in our Thursday Meet the Critters series! We’re into our fifth month, and still have plenty of fresh faces to try and find a best side for… and this week, we’re going to take a look at the Shelf’s designated ovine and see why there’s something about Mary…
NAME: Mary Mutton. Her last name hasn’t been used since her debut episode (see below)…
SPECIES: Sheep, though she prefers to be called a lamb because a lamb sounds much more adorable than a sheep.
SHELF PERSONALITY: Mary is the biggest tease on the Shelf. She’s cute and she knows it, and uses that to her advantage to get what she wants out of the malecritters. Consider Mary to be a more sarcastic and brainier version of Mitzi…

You know studmuffin, it you’d rather play with bags full of silicone, there’s some plastic Jello cups in the fridge I can get for you…
RUNNING GAGS: Because Mitzi is already established as SCT’s official sex kitten, Mary is extremely jealous of her and often looks to put Mitzi down while flaunting her own natural adorability over Mitzi’s bimbo makeup. Her sweet, seductive eyes draw the men in like flies, but unlike with her rival, it’s always up in the air whether Mary’s in the mood to be a baaaaaaaad girl or not.
ESN PREMIERE: Amazingly, I never considered pulling Mary off the Shelf for even a cameo until last Fall’s episode “Talentless Show,” where I intentionally brought a bunch of my previously unused critters out of the bleachers to audition for a role in Shelf Critter Theatre. Although, like the rest of the contestants that day, Mary met a bad ending… she was the only newbie from that American Idol parody to break out and become a semi-regular character in the series. In that episode, she was billed as Mary Mutton, though the last name has never come up again…
ICONIC SCT ROLE: Mary hasn’t had any starring roles yet, though maybe her best appearance came in this year’s Easter episode “Bad Eggs,” where she helps the clueless Bad Santa learn how to do the absent Easter Bunny’s job. It doesn’t work out very well, but a good time was still had by all…
WHAT’S IN A NAME?: Mary just seemed like a natural name for a lamb given the nursery rhyme that her and Mitzi helped skewer last week. She just looks like a Mary.
WHAT IS SHE?: Like a lot of her SCT brethren, Mary was once just a common, ordinary Happy Meal toy distributed by McDonald’s. She is a Littlest Pet Shop bobblehead critter from a 2011 promotion that, so far as I can tell, has no official name.
WHERE DID SHE COME FROM?: Almost certainly from my Happy Meal ordering mother, though I don’t know when or why Mary came into my possession.
CAN I GET ONE TOO?: Absolutely, if you wanted to pay $4 for her plus over double that in shipping and “handling” charges. I also discovered that there is apparently a blog dedicated to McDonald’s Happy Meal toys throughout the years that boasts posts on at least 10,000 individual toys. Here’s the page for Mary. Unfortunately, Mary doesn’t have a “story” for her write-up… and I have a feeling the blogger would not want to include any of Mary’s escapades on The Shelf in her bio, though I’d imagine that prevert Grimace would appreciate reading what she’s up to…
I’ll feature another critter next Thursday who is just too cute for their own good…
you had a Mary in your happy meal? we got crayons and a coloring book… how boring, only good to ruin the car…. I’m off to the Golden Seagull now … maybe I will get a Mary too…
If you do get a Mary, I’d check the expiration date on the food since the toy was retired seven years ago! Maybe you will get a Fleabag…
Adorable little lamb. Awwwwww.
Best eyes in my bunch…
Natalie’s youngest – Harper age 6- want one of the unicorns she just saw! Thanks a lot!!
Anyone ever tell you that you have a warped mind?? LOL! 😅😅😅
A few times. And I think you account for half of them… 😛
Lol!!
If I had ONLY been more dedicated to Happy Meals, MY house could be full of critters. Oh, wait. My house IS full of critters. Living and not so living. On shelves and all over the sofa. Hairy and bronze … But some don’t have names and I am deeply ashamed. But I do have HUNDREDS of old dolls and every one of them has a name. One of them even got a letter. From the post office. So there.
Most of your dolls and critters have some kind of real value while mine are valuable only to me and the literally sixes of people who read these stupid stories I put together. Shelf Doll Theatre would be interesting, but probably not a good idea with the tres perros…
Snorts and shakes my piggy head. I will never look at sweet Mary again the same way!! XOXO – Bacon
She looks so sweet and innocent that her naughty behavior always catches me by surprise!
She does! Mary was supposed to be a toy that would bring happiness to a little girl, and I turned her into a perv. Just like Mitzi was supposed to be some girlfriend’s Valentine’s Day gift, and……. well, she’s ruined the reputation of stuffed unicorns everywhere!
She’s such a cutie it’s hard to believe she’s so naughty, such a naughty, bad lamb, a naughty, naughty… sorry, got carried away there.
LOL! Keep trying and she may shake her lamb’s tail for you…
I’m guessing that she’s not a fan of mint, though? Or maybe she is, if she’s that perverted…